Insomnia review by Yoosuf
Not Entirely What I Expected

I pretty much yawned through the trailer for this film a couple of months ago. A psychological thriller set in the land of moose and tundra, it featured scenes of Al Pacino chasing Robin Williams across rocky, river beds and floating logs. Big freakin’ whoop.

What this film delivered was a no non-sense trip through the psyche of a veteran detective, Will Dormer (Pacino), as he strives to unravel a brutal murder before the continuous sunlight of the Alaskan sky and resultant sleep deprivation unravels his last nerve. Not helping the situation is an Internal Affairs investigation waiting for him back at his home office in L.A., threatening to uncover some shady investigative work that could land Dormer in court and every convict he helped put away back on the street.

Even worse, Dormer learns his partner, Hap (Martin Donovan), plans to cut a deal with the I.A., saving his own hide and potentially putting Dormer on the street. As if things weren’t going well enough, Dormer “accidentally” shoots and kills Hap while tracking down their murder suspect in a dense fog. Hap actually dies believing his partner maliciously shot him, and Dormer’s quick mind concedes to frame the still unknown suspect, thus deflecting any blame for the shooting. Now Dormer’s guilty conscious, partnered with the constant daylight, nags his soul and his ability to sleep (ah, hence the name of the film). But now making matters even worse . . . well I’ll stop there.

"HOOHAH!!! vs. NANO NANO!!!”"

I found it a pleasure to watch Pacino’s character quickly degenerate from a position of power and authority to one of utter desperation and guile. Pacino has been doing cop and detective roles for years, so there’s little stretch of the imagination watching his character play chess games with evidence and profile the murderer based solely on the victim’s body. The film puts him front and center in almost every scene, and his aged and lively face keeps the dialogue believable and interesting.

We’re seeing an interesting change in the roles Robin Williams is taking lately. While “Death to Smootchy”, “Patch Adams”, and other films have shot his dignity in the foot (okay, like he had much before), his role in this film ought to seriously remind people of the actor he can be (Dead Poet’s Society). I didn’t think Mr. Peter Pan was going to cut it as a sinister murderer, but he surprisingly fits the glove. He’ll be doing it again in an upcoming film, “One Hour Photo”. There were instances reminiscent of the movie “Seven” where we see control of the situation swap between the investigator and the suspect. The interplay between Dormer and Williams’ character, Walter Finch, is subtle and heavily psychological, and made members of the audience smile as they realized the direction the story was taking.

Hilary Swank plays Ellie Burr, the wide-eyed Alaskan native investigator who idolizes Dormer. Watch her character develop in this movie, cause you really see her mature as she goes about systematically unraveling the lies and cover-ups perpetrated by both Dormer and Finch. She’s good eye candy, but doesn’t take off anything more than a vest or a parka. Maura Tierney (cute chick from “Newsradio”) plays a small but interesting role as well. Again, no skin show there (she plays a damn innkeeper too, it would’ve been trivial for her to, you know, provide at least a little “room service”.)

Bottomline: This movie has some action, but I wouldn’t dare call it an action flick (see above: old guys running). This is a movie that wants you to think, and the superb acting facilitates your penetration into the characters’ minds and motives. I held my breath a couple of times, and the plot development did make me say, “I’ll be damned” once or twice. Nudity? Sure. A flat-chested chick on an autopsy table. That’s all you get. Shooting? Yeah, a little, but nothing too flashy. My overall impression is wait for the DVD/video and rent it. The big screen and surround sound is only good for a haunting score and a few dramatic views of the gorgeous scenery (British Columbia, not really Alaska, ooh that spoiled it for ya, didn’t it). But if you’re sick of the kiddy action flicks (Attack of the Clones and Spiderman), Insomnia makes a nice alternative.
Yoosuf Rating: 7 1 Jackass 1 Jackass 1 Jackass 1 Jackass 1 Jackass 1 Jackass 1 Jackass
Number of Hits: 648 Recent: 648 Review by:Yoosuf
This person doesn't review here much anymore, so we aren't going to bother typing anything funny about them...
Average Rating:7.000000
Reviewers Last 5 Reviews

Insomnia - 7 out of 10
- 0 out of 10
- 0 out of 10
- 0 out of 10
- 0 out of 10
Number of
Movies Reviewed
:
1
Median Rating:6
Mode Rating:7
Reader Ratings:7.000000
Jackass Average:6.252600
Reviewer is more generous than your average Jackass.


Similar reviews:
Memento by Da Bonghit - 8 out of 10. (Same director)
One Hour Photo by The Grim Ringler - 8 out of 10. (Same actor)
The Core by Mike Long - 5 out of 10. (Same actor)
The Gift by Tom Blain - 6 out of 10. (Same actor)
Following by Matt Fuerst - 10 out of 10. (Same director)
Batman Begins by Matt Fuerst - 7 out of 10. (Same director)
Batman Begins by The Grim Ringler - 9 out of 10. (Same director)
RV by Mike Long - 4 out of 10. (Same actor)
The Night Listener by Mike Long - 5 out of 10. (Same actor)
The Prestige by Mike Long - 5 out of 10. (Same director)
VISITOR REVIEWS
Average User Rating is a 7
jcasetnl7June 26th, 2002
I agree with most of the other comments. This film is light on action and yet not overly heavy, intellectually.

My main problem with it is I just don't care about the Pacino character. He shows up in Alaska and very shortly thereafter we find out about the Internal Affairs situation. And very shortly thereafter he accidently shoots his partner. And very shortly thereafter he starts dealing with all the consequences that implies. We could have used some flashback scenes or a bit more emotionally involving background information. Otherwise Pacino is just some guy who flew into town and dumped his problems in our lap.

Hillary Swank was surprisingly good in this role. I really expected an amateur performance from her. In a couple of moments she is, but this is clearly the fault of the script. The scenes where she tries to write down bits of conversation between her and Pacino should have been left out of the film, for example. There are much better ways to convey her "green-ness".

Robin Williams is incredibly versatile but still no one believes it. He's done everything from Mrs. Doubtfire to the Birdcage, to Dead Poet's Society to The Fisher King and still everyone shakes their heads at whatever roles he takes thinking he's miscast. Most likely because most of his roles include his type-cast comedic style. But I digress. He was good, but not great in this film. He plays the "He was a quiet man, very likable" part of the killer well but I didn't get enough sense of the lunatic lurking just beneath the surface.

Overall I think this movie could have used another 15 minutes for us to get more familiar with the characters so we can understand the full gravity of what the Internal Affairs investigation means for Pacino. The movie could have opened with Pacino wrapping up his last case before heading to Alaska or with the IA guys staring over his shoulder as he's given his new assignment. Anything that allows us to feel the character a little more.

fuersty7June 2nd, 2002
Well, it won't blow your socks off, but it's enjoyable enough. Robin Williams indeed did manage to tone it down, thank goodness. Also, note the way Al Pacino holds a phone, it's how I do it when I have drank about 17 beers in two hours... I just find it endlessly curious.



I find it kind of funny that Tom has complained about the ending now on both Chris Nolan flicks. I can't wait to hear his critique of his third mainstream film.. I can see the headline now "Great movie, rip-off ending."
Tom Blain7May 30th, 2002
Pretty good first review Yoosuf.

This movie was overall well-done. Riding the hype of Memento, Chris Nolan follows up as good as anyone could have. The characters are well crafted and well played. Pacino and Williams (both notorious for overacting) are delightfully toned down. The plot is pretty damn good as the morality of pacino parallels the that of William's character. The difference is one is a cop and one is a criminal. And the scenery is phenomenal. Makes me want to take trip to alaska with 20 rolls of film.

I do have a problem with the ending though. Its a bit overly dramatic. But doesnt spoil the rest of the movie by far. Nothing completely outstanding but a good thinking mans thriller/mystery.
New Review

VISITOR COMMENTS
Thomas BlainDecember 3rd, 2002Reply
What happened to this Yoosuf guy? One pump chump? Single review and out?

Also should we move this to DVD review along with Star Bore's 2?
    Matt FuerstDecember 5th, 2002
 Nah, it was a review of the film while in theatres, and there is no specific DVD content, so we meanaswell leave it here in the more general section.
Matt FuerstJanuary 27th, 2003Reply
I guess Yoosuf isn't coming back. This one is out on DVD now so I imagine it will be getting a lot more play these days.

If at all possible do yourself a favor and check out the original. Lots of cool atmopshere.
    Thomas BlainJanuary 28th, 2003
 Is the original available on Criterion Collection? Where can I get a copy?
October 31st, 2005Reply
damn, you jackass critics only think about the nudity of the female actress....females aren't animals and you can also comment their actress hability....not only their non-nudity..
Enter your comment: (No HTML allowed)
Name:
REPEAT NUMBER:
<-You must enter NUMBER for post to save!
E-Mail
(Optional):
Comment: